Quote from: Matt
hi, maybe it works differently on other servers, but on Hades anyway, your walkthrough will get you a "decent" rating almost every time. I did this quest 3 times tonight(4 times total). The first two I tried doing it your way and only got a "Decent", and then I just matched up all my left pieces with the right pieces given to me by my partner and got a "Perfect". That is:
Amour Right + Amour Left
Desire Right + Desire Left
Attraction Right + Attraction Left
Romance Right + Romance Left
If you do that you will get a perfect every time. If you match it by what the NPC tells you you will only get a decent(unless you just happen to get lucky with what they randomly say). Just ignore what the NPC's tell you because they're either lying or the game code just doesn't know how to differentiate. Each race of NPC will always give you the same kind of chocolate though. In Bastok the Mithra/Galka are Attraction, the Tarutaru are Desire, the Elvaan are Romance and the Humes are Amour.
I dunno if that changes on a day-to-day basis, but I'm willing to bet it doesn't.
I wish I had bet gil with the guy I was doing this quest with. He swore by this site's walkthrough and I would have won that bet.